Search Articles:

Overwood & Delamination Lead to Wood Floor Failure

By Jeff Pope
October/November 2008
print  Print          Download PDF

The Problem

I was commissioned by a wood flooring contractor to examine the quality of the wood flooring purchased by the homeowner and to inspect the wood flooring already installed in the basement of a magnificent new Georgia home.

The Procedure

The homeowner had chosen an unfinished engineered white oak ½-by-3 3/8 -inch floor in random lengths for his basement. He knew the flooring did not have a warranty but chose to have it installed anyway; it was glued to the basement slab with a moisture-cured adhesive. After the floor was installed and sanded, the homeowner walked over the floor and felt many boards flex. The contractor explained that more than 100 boards separated during the sanding process. He believed the homeowner had purchased a batch of defective flooring.

The Cause

The first thing I noticed was approximately 100 boards with raised edges and at least 100 with overwood at end joints. A number of boards had part of the surface missing. At end joints where the overwood was very noticeable, I slipped my prybar between the first and second layers of wood. The top layer easily pulled up. Next I lifted several boards glued to the subfloor. This was difficult: Each board split and broke into small pieces, so a hammer and wood chisel had to be used. All moisture testing indicated that the concrete subfloor and wood flooring were within an acceptable range.

Five boxes of unused wood were in the garage, and I inspected random pieces. Approximately 50 percent were defective. Boards had cracks along edges between the top and second layer, and several layers could be separated by hand. An inspection clearly showed an absence of adhesive between the top and second layers. Some boards had 4 to 10 inches without adhesive. It appeared that during manufacturing the adhesive applicator machine malfunctioned or ran out of adhesive; I believe the manufacturer found the error and sold the product as "defective" without warranty.

How to Fix the Floor

The homeowner realized the mistake, paid my client to remove the wood, and paid for the labor and costs to prepare the basement concrete for a second installation. He ordered a different unfinished engineered wood floor, but during the sanding process workmen noticed puckers along edges of boards and overwood at end joints. Again I was called; I examined the new wood and found the same defects as before—many boards could easily be pulled apart by hand. The homeowner said he wasn't going to pay for the labor and removal for the second floor, and things got interesting. It was my conclusion that the second conflict resulted from both product failure and negligence on the part of the wood flooring contractor.

In the Future

In a sense, a wood flooring contractor is the last "inspector" of a wood floor. Installers are generally considered responsible for checking the appearance of the boards (the correct grade, species, etc.), making sure the tongue and groove go together, and checking moisture content. Installers are not held responsible for structural errors in the construction of engineered flooring that may not be obvious until after installation. In this case, however, the flooring was so bad that a professional should have easily noticed this problem before installation and refused to install the floor. Even though the wood flooring contractor had no say in selecting the flooring, since he knew it came without a warranty, it would have been wise to check it more carefully (especially the second order). If he had, he would have noticed the problems before installation and avoided a messy dispute. If a customer insists on buying a product of questionable quality, sometimes the best choice is to walk away.

Jeff Pope is owner at Alpharetta, Ga.-based Jeff Pope Inc. and is an NWFACP-certified wood fooring inspector.

                    defective product   


Job Title:
Email (not published):
(maximum 2,000 characters)  

Related Articles: Troubleshooting

Sweaty Situation: Steamy Job Causes Unusual Stain Problem (August/September 2014 - Charles Peterson)
I was called by a high-quality flooring contractor recently because in 24 years of doing wood floors, he had never seen marks ...

Mysterious Moisture: This Moisture Meter Reading Didn’t Make Sense (June/July 2014 - Brian Gerello)
I was contacted by a hardwood floor installer in South Carolina to determine why his moisture meter was displaying...

Incompetent Installers Lead to 'Crackling' Wood Floor (April/May 2014 - Aaron Roworth)
We were called out to do an inspection on a floor that we had sold but had been installed by a third party. The ...

Q&As: Wood Species ID, Squeaks and Applying Hardwax Oil (April/May 2014 - HF Editors)
I need to do a repair on a floor where I can’t figure out the species...

Cupping by the Key: An Unexpected Source of Moisture in a Gym Floor (February/March 2014 - Kjell Nymark)
I was called to repair a gym floor previously installed at an elementary school here in the...

How Many Wood Floor ‘Failures’ Start Before the Sale (February/March 2014 - Roy Reichow)
Awhile back I was hired to do sales education training for a big flooring retailer, so ahead of time...

Heel Accessories Prevent Dents in Wood Floors (December 2013/January 2014 - Karly McMillan)
Fun fact that many wood flooring professionals are all-too-familiar with: A 125 pound woman...

Coming Undone: Do Climate Extremes Really Cause Delamination? (December 2013/January 2014 - Dr. Dirk Lukowsky)
As engineered wood flooring becomes more prevalent, we are seeing increasing numbers of cases of delamination...

Coming Apart at the Seams: The Dry Season Is Hard on this Bamboo Floor (December 2013/January 2014 - Joe Tedder)
A complaint came in that the planks from a floating strandwoven bamboo floor were pulling apart at the seams...

Bubbles in a Strand Bamboo Floor Create a Sticky Mess (October/November 2013 - Jason Cantin)
About six months after installation, bubbles started to appear on top of a strand bamboo floor...